Crenshaw garners Swimmer of the Decade honors after four years competing for the Moccasins' women's program. The Marietta, Georgia native led Florida Southern to four Top-15 finishes at the NCAA meet while collecting a total of 13 First Team All-America honors across seven events from 2012-13 to 2015-16. She was crowned NCAA champion in the 1000 Freestyle twice (2013, 2014) and once in the 1650 Freestyle (2013). Crenshaw was the SSC Swimmer of the Year twice and a First Team all-conference member four times. She was named Swimmer of the Meet following the 2014 league championship and won a combined seven individual SSC titles.